This table shows the FJH Proficiency Levels for standards-based grading. It has five columns, one for each level, and rows for Characteristics, Description, Traditional Grade, Rubric Grade, and GPA Comparison.  Level 0, No Evidence (red column)  Characteristics: No attempt; too little evidence. Description: Too little or no work was submitted to show evidence of the assessed standard. Traditional grade: I/F (Incomplete). Rubric grade: 0. GPA comparison: 0.0 to 0.666.  Level 1, Minimal (orange column)  Characteristics: Limited; major mistakes in several areas; can’t remember; significant gaps in understanding. Description: Demonstrates significant gaps in understanding the assessed standard. Guidance and practice are necessary to progress. Traditional grade: D-, D, D+. Rubric grade: 0.7, 1, 1.3. GPA comparison: 0.667 to 1.66.  Level 2, Approaching (yellow column)  Characteristics: Inconsistent; success in some areas, major mistakes in others; can remember; some gaps in emergent understanding. Description: Demonstrates an ability to communicate an emergent understanding of the assessed standard. Some gaps in understanding exist. Traditional grade: C-, C, C+, B-. Rubric grade: 1.7, 2.0, 2.3, 2.7. GPA comparison: 1.67 to 2.99.  Level 3, Proficient (green column)  Characteristics: Sufficient; success in each area, minor mistakes in others; can understand and apply; communicates meaningful understanding. Description: Demonstrates proficiency work by communicating a meaningful understanding of the assessed standard. Traditional grade: B, B+, A-. Rubric grade: 3.0, 3.3, 3.7. GPA comparison: 3.0 to 3.66.  Level 4, Mastery (blue column)  Characteristics: Exemplary; success in each area, very few mistakes in others; can analyze and create; effectively communicates and can flexibly apply. Description: Demonstrates complete and masterful work by effectively communicating and flexibly applying understanding of the assessed standard. Traditional grade: A. Rubric grade: 4.0. GPA comparison: 3.67 to 4.0.

Teachers at FJH use standards-based grading practices to measure what students know and can do. This is a quick rundown of what that means for you and your student.


What Is Standards-Based Grading?

The basic idea behind standards-based grading is that each assessment a student completes (an assignment, quiz, essay, etc.) is tied to an educational standard for the class. Student work is graded on a 4-point rubric scale.

Understanding the Scale

The easiest way for parents and students to understand the rubric is to compare it to traditional letter grades:

4 = A

3 = B

2 = C

1 = D

0 = F

The rubric also includes midpoints that correspond to grades such as B+ or C-. An image above defines each rubric level.

Note: Teachers may also give a score of 0. (zero with a decimal), which equals 59% on an assignment. This score is generally used when a student completed some of the work, but there isn’t enough evidence to show real learning on the standard.

Benefits for Educators

Standards-based grading is extremely useful for teachers. Rubric scores make it easy to see quickly how well each student understands the material. Teachers can then offer extension activities to students who already understand the content and remediation to those who need more support.

Grades also reflect what students actually know and can do relative to the course’s learning objectives. They are no longer inflated by participation-type activities, random extra credit, or assignments unrelated to the learning objectives.


Benefits for Students

This approach benefits students as well. Gone are the days when teachers covered content, tested it, and moved on. Under this system, if a student does not demonstrate proficiency on a standard, the content or skill is retaught, and the student has the opportunity to be re-graded on that standard.